For Next Halloween

Can we get Pumpkin Seeds and grow our own colors, and also can the Carving Kit be a recipe, craftable by tinkers ?  We should be able to craft those imo, let the Butchers drop something like weapons or some other rarity. @Kyronix

I like this idea...
I have went through about 80 carving kits trying to get the fairy
And its still not on a pumpkin!!!

I'd also like to be able to turn the green pumpkin
so I can make it look like a overgrown watermelon


I have always wondered...
why doesn't the butcher drop a butcher knife with awesome stats..
or have that yellow color that the pirates whip has

In defence of the Broadsword team new ideas are not that easy to come by. I don't speak for them but I'm sure they would welcome any suggestions for halloween or any other season you could come up with other then just "we want something new and awesome".

Sorry if that seems harsh but I just wasted a half hour trying to make it through the new bat-woman and if that's an example of the "new and original" fall TV season  I'll be spending a lot of time on the game.

PS I like the idea of a butcher knife drop. It might be an opportunity to rework the "Cold Blood" cleaver with a recipe.

• How about the pumpkins drop bits of obsidian that can make a witch statue or a zombie statue or a whole bunch of different halloween themed stautes to collect/trade. Maybe put in a list of say 20 dif ones to try and get.
• Make it so the pumpkins you kill drop collectable paintings or something.
• How about they remove all the 'old' trick or treat items that get tossed on the ground and introduce a bunch of new ones both deco and something USEFUL like spell storage books that you can remove spell scrolls from in all book types mage, necro, weaving, mystic etc.
• How about they put in a quest requiring you to kill holloween themed mobs that invade a town and offer some nice arifact level items both armor and weapons.  Similar to where you have low level mobs, working to higher level mobs til you get to the boss mobs, then it resets and you go again for the month of Oct/Nov etc
• How about they introduce a bunch of halloween themed recipes you can cook to give your char's boosts to mana regen or hp regen etc with the odd one turning you purple or something. 
• How about they put in a bunch of costumes to collect for a witch, warlock, etc either as minor items dropping in an invasion or by killing butchers if you wanna continue with them.
  

people have been asking for the zombie skeletons, pumpkins, etc at meet & greets.
This time of the year is so awesome with so much to do.
but since there is so much to do, its hard to make time to do it all.

I like that they have the trick or treat stuff from other years, but the drop rate of the new items is way too low. So far I was only able to make time for 1 hour of trick or treat at Luna. I managed to only get a ghost chair and a obsidian skull. Last year I spent days trying to get the dragon pumpkin. I did manage to get 5 of them, but that took way too long. 

Yup.  There is a large group that wants the Butchers and named Skeletons to stay as is each year.

I want one of the tricks to be blowing yer body apart again LOL

Ok well  you guys are all easily pleased it seems, I will come back in another 5-10 yrs and ask if  you are still happy doing the same old content over and over.  I for one am not.  Had more than 5 yrs of it now, something different would be nice.

MissE said:

Ok well  you guys are all easily pleased it seems, I will come back in another 5-10 yrs and ask if  you are still happy doing the same old content over and over.  I for one am not.  Had more than 5 yrs of it now, something different would be nice.

Can't recall if the Killa Pumpkins are Demon or Undead slayer - or neither? 

With the exception of the Bug report threads if you follow this format you will not be just considered an endless whiner or worse.

1. The issue you have a problem with.
2. What you see as a way to fix the problem or an event you think would be better and more entertaining   

If part 2 is not at least as long as part 1 think real hard about posting.

My part 2 is.

How about if next year we dropped Halloween and did Octoberfest instead. I could really get behind hunting down those *%&^$ bandits who were raiding the beer shipments. They could make it part of a rotating set of events. Maybe the next year base it on Englands Guy Fawkes, the year after some something seasonly appropriate from Japan. Once they had 3 or 4 worked out and in rotation it would be something to look forward to. And only coming up every 3rd or 4th year no-one would get bored. Remember Halloween is just a big thing in the US. As far as I know it's only spreading on "any excuse for a party is a good one" 

I think a lot of the planing could be farmed out as a contest to the local shard. A castle spot on Drachenfels for the best and most complete Octoberfest event plan for example.

Oh and I meant to add I prefer the new treasure hunting

The Trick or Treating is pretty bad. Or it's broken. Perhaps it's broken on some shards and not on others? I don't know. But it is pretty bad.

Yesterday another player and I thought for sure it was broken. We were both out for quite awhile and didn't get any drop at all. Not even the old stuff.

Just now I went non stop at Heartwood and Royal City for about 40-45 minutes. This was my haul...

A small grey spiderweb that won't show up anyway when you lock it down. 

The first day Trick or Treating was activated I got three of the new crystal skulls in a pretty short amount of time. Two of the pink Sonic the Hedgehog looking ones and a bright purple something or other. I don't like the colors of either of them. Day glow pastel colors don't speak Halloween to me. The blue and green skulls from last year look great. The blue looks like it could be glass or crystal. The green looks nice and creepy. But hot pink and purple? It feels like a shortcut on the artwork. 

More aggravating still is how unsatisfying the whole Trick or Treat mini-game is.  Since those first drops on day one I've gone trick or treating for about another 15-16 hours. I've not gotten a single other new item to drop since. Not one. Also on the first day, another player showed me a skull or mask of Sphynx head. Waaay better looking than the pink and purple skulls. Been looking for it ever since but have received nothing other than items from years past.

Spending this much time and not getting a single new drop feels broken to me. If I ever see another mini guillotine or iron maiden, or little ghost chair that you can't sit in, it'll be too soon. This should be more fun. At the very least rotate out the old inventory. Let us have a few new bits of artwork and revisit the old stuff again some time down the line when we'll be glad to see it again.

Trick or Treating to me, is like most other ingame games, your account is tied to it in some weird way. By this I mean, I never get anything good from this, I spend 95% of my time recovering from being Teleported, because tee hee hee, isn't that so much fun Devs ???? Gosh, it sure is....so this year I went out for exactly 3 minutes. I hit up 4 or 5 NPCs, and got teleported on 4 of them. No thanks. On a side note, for some reason I logged in this morning thinking "Ok, it's Oct 15th, surely there will be new items added to the Fellowship, especially the pumpkin head right ? I mean, surely you want to be able to get one of these during the actual month of October right ? Nah...

Ya its time for the rest of the items on the Fellowship vendor.

I would like to find a short Corgul trip and make a gate from the pumpkin rowboat and have a group squish onto it!

I didn't read much of this...but...I like how things are...I mean...when you're a kid..what do you do for Halloween every year? EVERY YEAR...the same thing....put on costume, go beg for candy SAME thing year after year after year....but you still did it...right? Even though you did it the halloween before and the halloween before that....

All the candy from ToT is worth 1 turn-in point...you know how many Turn-in points you can rack up doing ToT?  A LOT! 

I also spent 2 hours ToT'ing yesterday....I got a scarecrow and a chair in a ghost costume...and a LOT of turn-in points 🙂 I'm happy with that.

I do miss the named pumpkins...but glad that the ones I have are rare...even though I lost the one with my name on it I still have CatHats, Wilki, Draconi and others that I cherish every year. 

I still love the named skeletons in the graveyards....I still try to hope for the cool colors in every graphic...it's the collector in me...I have only ever gotten one red one.

Haven't done the High Seas Soulbound stuff....not my thing...not too happy that I feel left out of a Halloween Dungeon this year but a nifty idea to put it in the water to follow the publishes...very unique idea!

I was thinking about the bowl of candy I'd mentioned that would be a fun item to have for the season. Then I was thinking how fun it be if we could lock it down at our houses and Trick or Treaters could actually come and click on it and get a piece of candy or a chance at a rare drop.

It would get players out and about, visiting one another's houses, seeing the Halloween decorations and such. 

I put out a steward who has all sorts of stuff in his pack for giving out if the "right" words are spoken... all kinds of stuff, not just candy or standard things. From deco to rarities to artifacts and more. Since the steward hands out things randomly, it is kinda fun. 🙂 One year I filled him up twice.

Sorting things in my castles - so there will be plenty on him this year.

Would like to have a Large Round Bale of Hay that can be used as a decoration as well as optional holiday covers that can be applied over them.

Kirthag said:

I put out a steward who has all sorts of stuff in his pack for giving out if the "right" words are spoken... all kinds of stuff, not just candy or standard things. From deco to rarities to artifacts and more. Since the steward hands out things randomly, it is kinda fun. 🙂 One year I filled him up twice.

Sorting things in my castles - so there will be plenty on him this year.

Can you put a bags of stuff on the steward and he give a bag to each person?

yes

I don't mind them reusing the same content year after year but what i would like to see is the older items (previous years rewards) drop off and no longer available.  It would make each years rewards unique and a little more valuable.
This could be applied to trick or treating,  Krampus,  pumpkin patches,  graveyards,  horn of plenty,  treasures of doom and the Christmas tree BoD turn in thing (the name eludes me atm) 

Headless helm that makes your head invisible. Reforgable and imbueable.

Grimm mask. Dyeable, reforgable, and imbueable.

TimSt said:

Grimm mask. Dyeable, reforgable, and imbueable.

I kinda like the idea of a wearable Grimm mask.
I think Get Off My Lawn would look cool with an evil clown mask lol
or make it to where you can add the masks already in game to its own totem.
Like they did for costumes.
And about costumes... I want a changeling costume

but seriously, if they added the Grimm masks to totems, add the skulls from TOT too.
I would love to have a character run around with a crystal skull as a face...
would also love if they would add a fire skull... with flames all over

Mariah said:

yes

Thanks.  I had some spare time today.  I put bags of empty soulbinders on a Steward and now others can grab binders when I am not around.